Fundoplication in chronic intractable cough
© Faruqi et al.; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. 2012
Received: 5 April 2012
Accepted: 29 June 2012
Published: 19 July 2012
Skip to main content
© Faruqi et al.; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. 2012
Received: 5 April 2012
Accepted: 29 June 2012
Published: 19 July 2012
Airway reflux is a common cause of chronic cough and this is often refractory to medical therapy. Surgery in the form of Nissen fundoplication has been highly successful in the treatment of the classic reflux symptoms of heartburn and dyspepsia. There is a paucity of data regarding response to fundoplication in patients presenting with chronic cough.
We retrospectively reviewed the case notes of patients from the Hull Cough Clinic who had undergone Nissen fundoplication over the past 6 years. Demographic details, duration of symptoms, presence of other symptoms, results of oesophageal studies, outcome and complications were recorded. Patients were contacted by post and asked to complete a questionnaire detailing current symptoms. In a subgroup with continued troublesome cough 24 hour pharyngeal pH measurements were undertaken.
Forty seven patients underwent fundoplication. The average duration of pre-operative cough was 8 years. Gastro intestinal symptoms were present in the majority. In 30 (64%) patients a positive response to treatment was recorded. Mild dysphagia or bloating was seen in 18 patients following surgery. Four patients needed repeat surgical intervention for modification of fundoplication. One patient developed aspiration pneumonia eight weeks following surgery and died of a myocardial infarction. Two thirds of patients with persisting cough had evidence of airway reflux on pharyngeal pH monitoring.
In these patients with intractable cough a long term response rate of 63% represents a useful therapeutic option. Treatment failure is more frequent than for classic peptic symptoms and may be related to persistent gaseous reflux.
In a number of prospective series gastro-oesophageal reflux disease (GORD) has been demonstrated to be associated with chronic cough. This association has led to the implication that GORD is a causal factor in its pathogenesis. However, classical GORD symptoms of “heart burn” and “dyspepsia” are often absent in patients with other manifestations of airway reflux. Non or weakly acid reflux has also been implicated in the genesis of chronic cough. This suggests that the reflux causing cough is unlike that causing GORD and may be non acidic or even gaseous in nature. Whilst anti-acid medications are effective in treating the classical peptic symptoms of GORD and an empirical therapeutic trial is recommended in guidelines on the management of reflux associated cough the efficacy of this treatment is much more modest [1–3]. This suggests that an alternative treatment strategy aimed at preventing all forms of reflux may have a role.
Surgical treatment of reflux by means of fundoplication, performed using open or laparoscopic techniques, is thought to provide an effective mechanical barrier to gastro-oesophageal reflux and eliminates both acid and non-acid components. A number of studies have shown that fundoplication provides excellent short and long term control of peptic symptoms. The most commonly performed procedure is the Nissen fundoplication [4, 5]. This was initially described as an open procedure and the laparoscopic technique has evolved in the past twenty years .
Although there are several reports of anti reflux surgery in patients with “atypical” respiratory, or laryngeal symptoms [7–30], very few studies are devoted to patients with chronic cough as the presenting symptom [13, 16, 23, 24]. Limitations of these studies include small numbers and lack of follow up. Here we report the short and long term response in patients with reflux associated chronic cough who underwent laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication. This was a retrospective review and postal survey of patients referred for laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication from the Hull Cough Clinic.
All patients undergoing laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication at Hull and East Yorkshire Hospitals Trust from May 2003 to April 2009 who had been referred from the Hull Cough Clinic were identified. Patients had been selected for surgery on the basis of a clinical diagnosis of reflux associated chronic cough using our previously described criteria . Patients had to have failed multiple medical therapeutic trials for reflux associated cough as well as eosinophilic airway disease and rhinitis/post nasal drip. These included acid suppressive therapy, prokinetics, baclofen, inhaled cortico-steroids and first generation antihistamine. Our medical treatment algorithm for reflux associated cough includes 8 week sequential therapeutic trails of acid suppressive therapy (lansoprazole 30 mg bd with ranitidine 300 mg at night), prokinetics (metoclopramide 10 mg tds followed by domperidone 10 mg tds) and baclofen (5 mg tds and increased depending upon response/tolerance to 10 mg tds) for its action on the lower oesophageal sphincter. All patients recruited gave written informed consent for laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication. They had undergone a standard set of pre operative assessments which included 24 hour ambulatory oesophageal pH monitoring and manometry. The pH monitoring studies were done off and acid suppressive therapy. All patients had a chest radiograph which was normal. The case notes of all the patients identified were reviewed in detail by SF. The demographic details, duration of symptoms, prior medical treatment, results of investigations and recorded response to surgery and complications of laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication were elicited. Study approval was obtained from the hospital audit committee and confirmed by the ethics committee of Hull and East Riding, UK.
As previously described oesophageal motility was assessed by solid-state manometry . Ambulatory 24 hr oesophageal pH was measured at a level of 5 cm above the pre determined (via oesophageal manometry) upper border of the lower oesophageal sphincter (LOS). Data was presented as DeMeester score or percentage time the pH <4.
Laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication was performed in a standard fashion under general anaesthesia with full muscle relaxation using a five port technique . In every case the oesophageal hiatus was fully dissected and the oesophagus mobilised. At least one non absorbable suture was placed to approximate the crura posterior to the oesophagus and to minimise the risk of post-operative herniation. In cases where there was a large pre-existing hiatal defect, additional posterior crural sutures were placed as required. In most cases there was no obvious hiatus hernia demonstrated at surgery. Calibration of the oesophageal hiatus was clinical but in cases of doubt a 56 Fr endoluminal bougie was available to calibrate the appropriate size.
All patients identified were contacted by post in August 2009 and were asked to complete and return a questionnaire. This questionnaire included 100 mm visual analogue scales (VAS) to assess cough and heart burn/indigestion. Patients were asked to indicate on the VAS what they perceived their symptoms were like prior to the surgery and what they were like now (at the time of completing the questionnaire). The scale ranged from “not troubled” to “extremely troubled”. They were similarly also asked to complete the Hull Airway Reflux Questionnaire (HARQ), a self administered airway reflux specific questionnaire . Option to indicate in free text anything else related to either their symptoms, complications or the surgery was also present in the questionnaire.
The short term outcome was decided upon review of the case notes. Response of cough to laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication was divided into three categories: complete response, partial response and lack of response. Documentation in the notes that the cough had either resolved or ceased to cause any substantial discomfort was categorised as a complete response. If it was documented that there was an improvement in cough but the cough had not completely resolved and was causing significant problems it was categorised as a partial response. Lack of response was documented as such. Similarly the outcomes of “heart burn” and/or “indigestion” if present were recorded.
The long term outcomes were decided based upon the VAS scores for cough from the questionnaires returned. VAS scores for both cough and the peptic symptoms were used.
Complications post procedure were recorded on review of case notes and returned questionnaires.
Pharyngeal airway pH monitoring (Restech) was performed on patients continuing to complain of reflux-associated cough following laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication. A probe is placed in the oropharynx via the nasal route and monitors the pH in the surrounding environment over 24 hours. Sampling frequency (2 Hz) is sufficient to detect short lived, gaseous reflux events which may be responsible for triggering cough. Analysis uses a composite scoring system (Ryan score) based on frequency and duration of episodes where the pH crosses a lower threshold . Studies are scored separately in the upright and supine positions.
Demographics and other applicable data are presented descriptively. The VAS scores for cough and peptic symptoms were analysed by the Wilcoxon signed-rank test. Fischers exact test was performed to look for predictors of successful response of cough to laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication. P value of <0.05 was taken as being significant. Statistical analysis was performed using SPSS statistical software package, Chicago, Illinois, USA.
Patient characteristics and outcome
Age (Median, Range)
Duration of cough in years (Median, Range)
Peptic symptoms present in
Significant acid reflux present in
Decreased lower oesophageal sphincter pressure
Response to treatment
The primary short term outcome of improvement in cough was seen in 30 patients (64%). The response was complete in 45% and partial in 19%. Following surgery peptic symptoms improved in all patients. This is summarised in Table 1.
Long term outcomes
Median (range) VAS score for cough
On follow up
44 (0–100), (p < 0.001)
Median (range) VAS score for heart burn/indigestion
On follow up
16 (0–100), (p < 0.001)
Median (range) VAS HARQ score
On follow up
28 (0–61), (p < 0.001)
The factors looked at were gender, presence of heart burn/dyspepsia, abnormal acid reflux on 24 hour pH recording, presence of oesophageal dysmotility and decreased lower oesophageal sphincter tone. None of these parameters were a significant discriminator of outcome.
In twelve patients who remained symptomatic post-laparoscopic fundoplication pharyngeal pH studies were performed. Mean HARQ score in this group was 44.2. Eight studies were positive in the upright position (mean Ryan score 83.9, ULN 9.41). All 12 studies were negative in the supine position.
Seventeen patients perceived dysphagia following surgery. In 14 the dysphagia was mild and did not need any specific intervention. In 3 patients the Nissen fundoplication needed conversion to a partial (270°) fundoplication and in one patient the fundoplication was reversed. Three patients perceived a sensation of bloating. Two patients complained of discomfort as they were not able to vomit. One patient developed a small left sided pleural effusion post operatively. This resolved without any specific treatment. A 43 year old woman had recurrence of dyspeptic symptoms and cough two years following fundoplication. Dyspeptic symptoms had resolved and cough had improved, the response being partial, following the procedure. On investigation the fundoplication wrap was found to be partially undone. She had a further procedure to ensure effective fundoplication which led to the amelioration of dyspeptic symptoms and improvement in cough, which again was partial. A 69 year old woman had an episode of aspiration pneumonia eight weeks following surgery and suffered fatal myocardial infarction.
We have demonstrated in our study that around two thirds of patients with reflux associated chronic cough have a significant response to Nissen fundoplication. Of the responders two thirds have a very good response with either complete resolution of cough or reduction in cough to levels which were no longer perceived to be a problem. This response was sustained on long term follow up. As suggested by the VAS scores, our patients suffered from debilitating chronic cough which we and others have demonstrated to have a profound impact on quality of life. The post operative reduction in VAS score was not uniform but in those who responded represents a marked improvement. Free text comments written on the questionnaire included “My life was pure hell before the operation”, “The operation changed my life” and “Delighted and would recommend to anyone…”. When successful it is clearly a valuable treatment option.
Reflux has been increasingly implicated in the pathogenesis of cough in patients presenting to specialist cough clinics . Lack of consensus on diagnostic criteria of extra-oesophageal reflux makes it difficult to exactly quantify the association. Conventional criteria based on duration of oesophageal acid exposure observed in twenty four hour pH studies are applicable only to the peptic symptoms of GORD. Impedance measurements demonstrate that non/weakly acid reflux is responsible for many extra-oesophageal symptoms such as cough and dysphonia . Our data suggests that persistent gaseous reflux occurs in patients failing fundoplication. Thus the nature of reflux leading to cough may be different from that causing GORD in that non acid, gaseous refluxate has a leading role.
In the absence of good objective diagnostic tests the clinical history is important in establishing the diagnosis of reflux associated chronic cough. Symptoms which suggest the diagnosis include: cough on phonation, on rising from bed, associated with certain foods or eating . In the validation of our questionnaire, HARQ, designed to detect airway reflux “heart burn” or “indigestion” had the weakest predictive probability .
One third of patients had little or no response in terms of cough although improvement in the symptoms of heartburn and regurgitation (data not shown) was almost invariable. The relatively high numbers of patients with reflux related cough having dyspeptic symptoms in our cohort may reflect our bias in selecting those with additional symptoms known to improve with fundoplication. In fact, the presence of dyspepsia did not predict a successful outcome in cough, suggesting different mechanisms underlying the genesis of these symptoms. In patients not responding to Nissen fundoplication pharyngeal pH monitoring demonstrated significant persistent reflux in the majority. Unlike the liquid reflux of GORD which is eliminated by fundoplication the gaseous reflux causing cough may persist.
There is a significant complication rate associated with fundoplication, chief of which are gas bloat and dysphagia. Unfortunately, we were unable to identify factors predicting a successful outcome and so in those patients with isolated cough careful consideration of the risk benefit ratio is required. Laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication can be taken down if there are intolerable complications and no benefit and we have undertaken this in one patient in this cohort.
There have been a number of reports of the experience of fundoplication for a variety of indications including patients with respiratory symptoms. Allen and Anvari reported their cohort of 905 . Of the 209 patients with some respiratory symptoms, 83% had cough. Cough was reported to have improved in 83% at 6 months, 74% at 2 years and 71% at 5 years. Kaufman et al. reported the retrospective long term outcomes in 750 patients who had undergone fundoplication of whom 231 had experienced cough, hoarseness or wheezing once per week . At a median follow up of 53 months there was a durable and statistically significant fall in cough assessed by a symptom questionnaire. Resolution of cough was observed in 41% and improvement in 74%. Very few studies have looked into chronic cough alone as a primary indication for fundoplication. In the largest, a prospective study of 21 consecutive patients undergoing Nissen fundoplication for reflux associated chronic cough complete resolution was observed in 62% and considerable improvement in 76% . Thus the results of our study are very similar to that reported in literature.
Laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication is a relatively safe procedure. In a retrospective review of over 2000 anti-reflux procedures 1 death was observed . Another study of 148 procedures reported peri-operative morbidity and mortality to be 8.8% and 0.7% respectively . Relatively mild complications of Nissen fundoplication are gastro-paresis, dysphagia and bloating. Because of the nature of the procedure a transient degree of dysphagia is experienced. In a majority of patients this improves without the need for any specific intervention. Rarely either a reversal, conversion to a partial fundoplication or oesophageal dilatation is needed.
Our study was retrospective follow up of patients and lacked a control arm. Cough therapy is known to have a strong placebo effect and this cannot be ruled out even in a patient population that had repeatedly failed medical therapy. Ideally we would have investigated pharyngeal pH pre and post operatively; however this testing was not clinically indicated and would therefore have required informed consent. This would have also proved prohibitively expensive. We used a VAS score to evaluate response to treatment and this may be subject to a “recall” bias. All other studies evaluating the role of anti-reflux surgery on chronic cough are also uncontrolled and not blinded. They also differ in the basis on which a diagnosis of reflux associated chronic cough and how the outcome was assessed. A randomised controlled trial is urgently needed to fully evaluate this treatment.
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.